the feedback project is about communication (Creative Writing)
ianglass:
Some people enjoy critiques and change their writing accordingly, trusting the opinion of another more than their gut feeling. If that’s your bag, than do what you do. But I try to be as separate as possible. Of course I can only separate to a certain extent— all is co-dependent. There is a lot of useless information ingrained which I cannot seem to erase and it only limits me artistically. The truth is, some people have a knack and others don’t; some people are equipped and others are not. What I find unique is what is unique. But that doesn’t mean that anyone else will agree. Creative writing is all about selfishness and necessity…
Your idea about the function feedback and criticism is totally askew. It’s not about trusting someone else’s opinion over “your gut feeling”; it’s about having a new perspective, a fresh set of eyes looking at what you’ve created and telling you what they see. You seem to be forgetting that it’s an opinion, and that nothing said in a critique is an absolute. Per your last post, where you state that you don’t believe in criticism, you simultaneously render some shitty #spilled ink haiku worthy of the same merit as The Waste Land and reveal a cowardice and arrogance in your approach to writing. You most likely meant you don’t believe in criticizing the work of others, but you’re also saying you are completely closed to any disagreeable viewpoint of your own work. Writing is often a lonely pursuit, but it is not selfish to the point where you believe your own high opinion of your work above any other. No serious poet, novelist, screenwriter, or play write has published their work without the help of an editor.
In your genesis of #the feedback project, you specifically use the word critique. What is the point of have a tag based on writers providing feedback to other writers who are interested in having their work looked at seriously if there is no “criticism.” According to you, #the feedback project is exactly the same as #poetry and #spilled ink, only you’re encouraging people to take the time to write “I love this!” Why bother? If #the feedback project is just a new way to participate in the ego inflation, self-aggrandizement, and pandering that already runs rampant among the other literary tags, then there is no true feedback and I want no part in it.